豆包成人版

Skip to main content

Designing contracts for chaos

This policy brief explores why two Colombian transit systems diverged, and what it means for UK infrastructure.


Policy Brief


Long-term infrastructure contracts cannot anticipate every shock over their 20- or 30-year life. When the financial model breaks, rigid contracts offer no way to adapt and can paralyse the public authority that depends on them.

This policy brief by Miguel D铆az-Mart铆nez (Visiting Policy Fellow, Institute for Policy Research) draws on two Colombian transit systems that met that moment under identical national law and opposite fates: Bogot谩鈥檚 was restructured and survives; Bucaramanga鈥檚 collapsed into liquidation.

The decisive difference for Bogot谩鈥檚 success was not the contract鈥檚 wording but the institution behind it 鈥� a single authority able to act, the capacity to build a defensible case, and protection for the officials who put their names to the decision.

The brief sets out five conditions that determine whether adaptation is possible, and argues that flexibility must be engineered into contracts before a crisis arrives. It draws direct lessons for UK debates on HS2, the Private Finance Initiative, and the design of Great British Railways and bus franchising.

Published July 2026.

Accessible alternatives

If you need any of the attachments on this page in accessible formats such as braille, large print, audio transcript, or other file formats, please contact the owner of this page.